|
Red
Light Cameras:
Index to Court Transcripts, Briefs, and Decisions
If you would like to see the Industry's index of cases, it is here.
CASE
NAME/LOCALE,
YEAR
|
ISSUES
RAISED
|
MATERIALS
AVAILABLE
|
Arizona, 1992
|
Personal service of ticket
(required in AZ)
|
Appellate decision
|
Allen, San Diego, 2001
|
Overall control of system
|
Trial court decision
|
Fairfax, VA, 2001; Seattle,
2009
|
Various
|
Opening
brief (Motion in Limine)
|
Culver City, 2003
|
Various
|
Settled
Statement
|
WeHo, 2003
|
Various
|
Trial
transcript
|
Neill, Sacramento, 2003
|
Approach
Speed, Due Process
|
Trial
transcript, opening brief
|
Bohl, Sacramento, 2004
|
Hearsay
|
Appellate
decision,
article
|
Hawthorne, 2005
|
Identity
|
Trial
transcript
|
Fischetti (# 1), Costa
Mesa, 2005
|
Warning
tickets, overall control of system
|
Appellate
decision.
Includes briefs, etc.
|
Moore, Sacramento, 2006
|
Lack of
substantial evidence (calibration)
|
Appellate
decision.
Includes opening
brief
|
Nagai, Los Alamitos, 2007
|
Illegal contract (Defect #
10 - B)
|
Trial court decision
|
Anna V., Santa Ana, 2008
|
Warning
tickets, inspection, calibration, guidelines
|
Appellate
decision.
Includes trial
court decision, brief
|
No name, no city, 2008
|
Taping,
illegal contract (Defect # 10 - B)
|
Trial
'transcript' by defendant
|
Franco, Fullerton, 2008
|
Illegal
contract (Defect # 10 - B)
|
Appellate
decision.
Includes opening brief, City's motions and petitions
attempting to
overturn appellate decision
|
Fischetti (# 2), Santa
Ana, 2008
|
Warning tickets (Defect #
6)
|
Appellate decision
|
| In
re: Red Light Photo
Enforcement Cases, 2008 - 2009 (class action) |
Contingency contract,
unjust enrichment |
Pending: On hold at
Cal. Supreme Court |
Williams, Culver City, 2009
|
Mixed signal lights
(Defect # 7)
|
Appellate decision
|
Graham, Sacramento, 2009
|
Lack of substantial
evidence (no photo of light)
|
Appellate
decision, opening brief
|
Lori A.
& Murray, Santa Ana, 2009
|
Illegal contract (Def. # 10 - B), public
announcement
|
Trial court decision
|
Bullock, San
Mateo, Sept. 2009
|
Illegal contract (Def. # 10 - B)
|
Appellate decision
|
Lopez,
Daly
City, Dec. 2009
|
Illegal contract (Def. # 10 - B)
|
Appellate decision.
Includes briefs.
|
Schmidt,
San Mateo, Dec. 2009
|
Warning signs, control of system by
private company
|
Article about appellate decision.
More info coming soon!
|
Singh,
Newark,
Jan. 2010
|
Confrontation
|
Appellate decision, opening brief
|
Mustapha B., Santa
Ana, Jan. 2010
|
Lack of admissible evidence
(confrontation)
|
Appellate decision
|
Romero, Santa Ana,
Jan. 2010
|
Warning tickets (Defect # 6)
|
Appellate decision
|
Class
Action,
2010
|
All issues
|
Forming
|
For more info about filing a
brief, see "Briefs" in the Site
Index.
None of the appellate decisions above has been published.
California Rule
of
Court 8.1115 says:
"Except as provided in (b), an
opinion of a California Court of Appeal
or superior court
appellate division that is not certified for
publication or ordered published
must not be cited or
relied on by a
court or a party in any other action."
If you are thinking about trying your case, and are willing to fight to
be able to cite these unpublished decisions, please contact me.
These materials may be freely copied and distributed, so long
as credit is given
to highwayrobbery.net .
For more details about any of the cities mentioned above, see that
city's entry on the Camera Towns page.
---------------------------------
RED LIGHT CAMERAS
www.highwayrobbery.net
www.highwayrobbery.net
|
