RED LIGHT CAMERAS
www.highwayrobbery.net

Email Address
Site Index

Red Light Cameras: 
Index to Court Transcripts, Briefs, and Decisions


If you would like to see the Industry's index of cases, it is
here.

CASE NAME/LOCALE, YEAR
ISSUES RAISED
MATERIALS AVAILABLE
Arizona, 1992
Personal service of ticket (required in AZ)
Appellate decision
Allen, San Diego, 2001
Overall control of system
Trial court decision
Fairfax, VA, 2001; Seattle, 2009
Various
Opening brief (Motion in Limine)
Culver City, 2003
Various
Settled Statement
WeHo, 2003
Various
Trial transcript
Neill, Sacramento, 2003
Approach Speed, Due Process
Trial transcript, opening brief
Bohl, Sacramento, 2004
Hearsay
Appellate decision, article
Hawthorne, 2005
Identity
Trial transcript
Fischetti (# 1), Costa Mesa, 2005
Warning tickets, overall control of system
Appellate decision.  Includes briefs, etc.
Moore, Sacramento, 2006
Lack of substantial evidence (calibration)
Appellate decision.  Includes opening brief
Nagai, Los Alamitos, 2007
Illegal contract (Defect # 10 - B)
Trial court decision
Anna V., Santa Ana, 2008
Warning tickets, inspection, calibration, guidelines
Appellate decision.  Includes trial court decision, brief
No name, no city, 2008
Taping, illegal contract (Defect # 10 - B)
Trial 'transcript' by defendant
Franco, Fullerton, 2008
Illegal contract (Defect # 10 - B)
Appellate decision.  Includes opening brief, City's motions and petitions attempting to overturn appellate decision
Fischetti (# 2), Santa Ana, 2008
Warning tickets (Defect # 6)
Appellate decision
In re:  Red Light Photo Enforcement Cases, 2008 - 2009 (class action) Contingency contract, unjust enrichment Pending:  On hold at Cal. Supreme Court
Williams, Culver City, 2009
Mixed signal lights (Defect # 7)
Appellate decision
Graham, Sacramento, 2009
Lack of substantial evidence (no photo of light)
Appellate decision, opening brief
Lori A. & Murray, Santa Ana, 2009
Illegal contract (Def. # 10 - B), public announcement
Trial court decision
Bullock, San Mateo, Sept. 2009
Illegal contract (Def. # 10 - B)
Appellate decision
Lopez, Daly City, Dec. 2009
Illegal contract (Def. # 10 - B)
Appellate decision.  Includes briefs.
Schmidt, San Mateo, Dec. 2009
Warning signs, control of system by private company
Article about appellate decision.  More info coming soon!
Singh, Newark, Jan. 2010
Confrontation
Appellate decision, opening brief
Mustapha B., Santa Ana, Jan. 2010
Lack of admissible evidence
(confrontation)
Appellate decision
Romero, Santa Ana, Jan. 2010
Warning tickets (Defect # 6)
Appellate decision
Class Action, 2010
All issues
Forming


For more info about filing a brief, see "Briefs" in the Site Index.

None of the appellate decisions above has been published.  California Rule of Court 8.1115 says:
"Except as provided in (b), an opinion of a California Court of Appeal
 or superior court appellate division that is not certified for publication or ordered published
 must not be cited or relied on by a court or a party in any other action."
If you are thinking about trying your case, and are willing to fight to be able to cite these unpublished decisions, please contact me.

These materials may be freely copied and distributed, so long as credit is given to highwayrobbery.net .

For more details about any of the cities mentioned above, see that city's entry on the Camera Towns page.



---------------------------------
RED LIGHT CAMERAS
www.highwayrobbery.net
www.highwayrobbery.net